A Trial Court Has Considerable Discretion In Ruling On A Motion To Sell Property That Is The Subject Of A Civil Forfeiture Action
UNITED STATES v. APPROXIMATELY 81,454 CANS OF BABY FORMULA (March 25, 2009)
Federal agents seized thousands of cans of powdered baby formula from a warehouse. They suspected that the cans had been stolen from retail stores. Many of the cans had altered labels - some of the cans were even past their "use by" date. The government filed a civil forfeiture suit, which is still pending in the district court. The owner of the cans asked the court for permission to sell those cans that were not yet beyond their “use by” date. The court denied the motion. The owner appeals.
In their opinion, Judges Posner, Sykes and Dow affirmed. The court first addressed the jurisdictional issue. Because the ruling on the motion was not a final appealable decision, the appellant relied on the "collateral order" doctrine. Under that doctrine, the Court noted, a party may take an immediate appeal from an order if it involves issues separate from those of the underlying litigation and there is a risk of irreparable harm. The Court found both criteria present in this case. The issues were clearly separate and, although unclear, the possibility of a monetary remedy from the government was unlikely.
On the merits, the Court noted that the procedural rules governing asset forfeiture actions were quite vague and provided no particular criteria for deciding a motion like the one presented to the court below. They do not, for example, as appellant argues, provide that the government has the burden of proof. The Court concluded that the lower court had considerable discretion in ruling on the motion. The judge below conducted an evidentiary hearing, where there was conflicting evidence concerning the threat posed by the formula. The Court could not conclude that the lower court abused its discretion in denying the motion.
Michael Rigney practices in the law offices of GVC Ltd. in Chicago. In this blog, he reports on select