Suicide Breaks A Chain Of Causation
JOHNSON v. WAL-MART STORES (December 1, 2009)
.jpg)
Candace Johnson visited her local Wal-Mart store in January 2008. Although she did not possess a Firearm Owners Identification Card, a salesclerk nevertheless sold her some bullets. Tragically, Candace Johnson then shot and killed herself. Her husband and the administrator of her estate, Mark Johnson, sued Wal-Mart for negligence and wrongful death. The district court dismissed the claims on the ground that suicide is an independent intervening event, negating proximate cause. Johnson appeals.
In their opinion, Judges Cudahy, Flaum and Evans affirmed. The Court recited the traditional elements of a negligence claim: a duty, a breach, and proximate cause. Historically, Illinois courts have found that suicide is unforeseeable and its presence breaks the chain of causation that is necessary for probable cause. The Court agreed that the sale of the bullets violated federal law and amounted to prima facie evidence of negligence, since the federal law is a public safety statute. The Court concluded, however, that Illinois courts continue to find that suicide breaks the chain of causation.
